top of page

Croatia by Rental Car or Private Transfer: Which Is Right for You?

Writer: Lucija Mandac Dadić
Lucija Mandac Dadić
Sep 29
8 min read

An honest local guide to choosing how to travel around Croatia


One of the first practical questions travellers ask us is: should we rent a car in Croatia, or arrange private transfers?

As a local travel designer, I usually answer with another question: do you enjoy driving on holiday? Not simply, are you able to drive—but would an open road and the freedom to stop feel like part of the experience, or would driving feel like one more responsibility?


Some travellers love choosing when to leave, taking a slower road and stopping when a small town or a beautiful view catches their attention. Others would rather settle into the back seat, look out at the landscape and know that the route, timing and parking have already been considered.


Neither way is more authentic, and neither one is always better. The right answer depends on your route, the time you have and, most importantly, how you would like the journey to feel.


"If you enjoy driving and have enough time to explore, a rental car can give you wonderful freedom. If your time is limited or you would rather not think about unfamiliar roads, parking and ferry logistics, private transfers can give you more time to relax. For many journeys, the best answer is a thoughtful combination of both."




When a private transfer gives you more of the day

Private transfers make sense when time, comfort and simplicity matter most. You do not need to collect a car, follow directions, manage tolls or find parking when you arrive. More importantly, you do not need to treat every change of destination as a day lost to travelling.


A transfer day can become part of the journey

When we connect Istria with Dalmatia, for example, we can plan the route through Plitvice Lakes National Park. It is still a long day, but it now has a reason. Instead of only leaving one hotel and reaching another, you walk through one of Croatia's most beautiful landscapes along the way.

On another route, the day might include a historic town, a local lunch, a winery or a place we know is worth stopping for. The idea is not to keep travellers busy every hour. It is to make better use of a journey they need to take anyway.


Sometimes the best route is across the sea

Private transfers are not limited to cars and vans. When an island is part of the journey, we also use private speedboats.

Travellers can be collected in Split or at a nearby marina and, for a nearby island such as Brač, arrive close to their hotel in around 20 to 30 minutes. On the right route, this can save up to two hours of travelling and waiting. We can use the same combination of a short road transfer and private speedboat for Split Airport. Weather permitting, it is one of the easiest—and loveliest—ways to begin or end an island stay.



A car should not spend its holiday in a garage

There are places where having a car simply does not add much. Dubrovnik is a good example. Most travellers explore the pedestrian Old Town, walk the city walls or spend a day on the sea. A rental car may remain in the hotel garage while they continue paying for both the vehicle and, sometimes, the parking.

The historic centres of Split, Rovinj and Hvar Town are also best enjoyed on foot. We usually choose centrally located accommodation so our travellers can step outside, have dinner, take an evening walk and enjoy the town without arranging transport each time. If most of the itinerary is built around central hotels, guided visits and boat experiences, a car may not be necessary for that part of the trip.



When the road is part of the experience

For travellers who genuinely enjoy driving, Croatia can be a wonderful country for a self-drive journey. The main regions are connected by good roads, and a car gives you the freedom to explore rural Istria, the Dalmatian hinterland, smaller villages, quieter beaches and viewpoints that would not naturally fit into a point-to-point transfer.

The important thing is not to treat the car only as a way of moving between hotels. If you choose to drive, the road should add something to your holiday.


Give yourself time to stop

When we include a rental car, we allow enough time for the drive to feel comfortable and suggest places where it is genuinely worth stopping. Some of my favourite views in Croatia are not at the end of a route. They appear somewhere between the better-known destinations, when the landscape changes from the hinterland to the coast or a small village invites you to stay for coffee.

We also avoid unnecessarily long drives at night. After an evening flight, it can make more sense to transfer to the hotel and have the car delivered the following morning. You begin rested, drive in daylight and pay for the car only when it becomes useful.


Plan food and wine days differently

A rental car is especially useful in Istria, where restaurants, villages and family-run properties are spread across the countryside. But a day centred on wineries or a truffle experience needs a slightly different plan.

In Croatia, wine is often part of the meal as well as the tasting. If you are driving, the safest choice is not to drink. For these days, we often arrange a private guide who is also the driver, so everyone can taste the wines, meet the winemakers and enjoy a long lunch without deciding who must drive back. For dinner, travellers may also leave the car at the hotel and use a taxi or ride-hailing service where available.

This is not a reason to avoid renting a car. It is simply a way to use it where it gives you freedom and leave it behind when another arrangement makes the day more enjoyable.


Taking a rental car to an island: allow more time than the map suggests

A car can be very useful on Brač or Hvar when you have several nights and want to explore beyond your hotel or main town. But the real travel time is not only the ferry crossing.

On many domestic vehicle-ferry routes, buying a ticket does not reserve a place for your car on one particular departure. Your place depends on when you join the queue and how many vehicles are already waiting. From the end of June through July and August, this can mean arriving well in advance and still waiting for the next available sailing.

Take Split to Hvar as an example. The vehicle ferry to Stari Grad takes around two hours. If you join the queue up to two hours earlier during a busy summer period, the journey may already use around four hours before adding the drives to and from the ports. A passenger-only fast ferry to Hvar Town takes roughly one hour.


For a longer stay, taking the car may still be completely worthwhile. For a shorter stay, we may instead bring travellers to the island as foot passengers or by private speedboat and arrange a rental car locally for one or two days. The right choice depends on what you want to experience once you arrive—not only on whether a car can travel with you.




You do not have to choose one option for the entire trip


Many travellers begin by thinking they need either a rental car for the whole journey or private transfers from beginning to end. In practice, a combination often creates the most natural rhythm.


You might rent a car for a few days in Istria, where independent exploring adds real value, and then return it before continuing towards Split, an island or Dubrovnik. Or you might arrive on Brač by private speedboat and have a car delivered locally for two days. Wine experiences can have their own driver, while the rest of the self-drive itinerary remains completely independent.


This is how we like to plan: not by applying the same transport to every day, but by looking at where each option genuinely improves the journey.


A real story from the road: when our local support mattered

A couple travelling with us chose this kind of mixed journey. They had a rental car for the part they wanted to explore independently, followed by private transfers when they wanted to slow down and relax. Their food and wine experiences had also been planned with a driver, so they could enjoy them fully.

During one of their longer driving days, they were waiting in line at a toll booth when the car in front unexpectedly rolled backwards into their rental car. The visible damage was very small, but it was a new vehicle and they were understandably unsettled. The other driver spoke very little English, and suddenly our travellers were standing beside the road in another country, unsure which documents the rental company and insurer would need.


They called us.


And they immediately reached the local person they already knew—their dedicated agent, who knew them and knew their journey. There was no anonymous call centre, no waiting for someone in another country or time zone to understand what was happening. Within minutes, we were speaking with our travellers and the other driver in Croatian.


We first reassured everyone and asked the clients to photograph the vehicles and all the necessary details. We contacted the rental company straight away, checked whether the police needed to attend in this situation and, together with our clients, completed the European Accident Statement. We then checked the documentation with the rental company so that everything had been done correctly for the insurance. Because comprehensive coverage had already been arranged, our travellers later returned the car at their hotel and continued their journey without further disruption.


We were genuinely happy that they knew exactly who to call, and very proud of how our team handled the situation. The accident was minor and it did not turn their self-drive journey into a negative experience. But it reminded us exactly what personal local support can mean when something unexpected happens: a familiar person answers, reacts in real time, speaks the language and knows what needs to happen next.


So, which is right for you?

If an open road, a good playlist and the freedom to stop in a small village sound like part of the holiday, a rental car may be one of the most enjoyable parts of your journey.


If driving would make you anxious, or if you would rather give your attention to the landscape and the people travelling with you, private transfers may be worth far more than the time they save.


And if different parts of the trip seem to need different answers, that is completely normal. The best itinerary is not the one that uses one transport style from beginning to end. It is the one that feels natural while you are travelling.


Our role is to listen, look carefully at the route and choose the right arrangement for each part of the journey. You are not simply deciding how to move through Croatia. You are deciding how you want your time here to feel.



Lucija Mandac Dadić, owner and travel designer at Local Heroes Travel

About the author


Lucija is the owner and travel designer behind Local Heroes Travel. Born and raised in Kaštela on Croatia’s Dalmatian coast, she uses her local knowledge and experience to create private, tailor-made journeys through Croatia, Slovenia and Montenegro.




Planning a private journey through Croatia?

Perhaps you already know that you love driving. Or perhaps you know that this is the one part of your holiday you do not want to think about. Both are good places to begin.


Tell us a little about your plans, how you like to travel and which experiences matter most. We will design a journey that uses a rental car, private transfers or a thoughtful combination of both—always with local support beside you.


A quiet bay on Croatia’s Adriatic coast


 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page